Nutter Butter, Are You Good? An Investigation.

Cassie Fitzwater hadn’t thought about Nutter Butter in years — until she saw the brutal crime scene photos.A post on TikTok showing the home of a peanut-butter-cookie family smeared in peanut butter gore — the aftermath of a double cookie homicide — left Ms.Fitzwater, 31, of Summersville, W.Va., “disturbed” and in “disbelief,” she said.Another recent video shows Nutter Butter cookies dancing as images of cats flood the screen and a distorted voice chants about the cookie.

Another, simply a shrimp being placed on top of a peanut-butter cookie to an applause soundtrack.In what feels like a cross between a Van Gogh painting, a ’90s MTV commercial and a rendition of a psychedelic trip, the sandwich-cookie company’s social media pages have caused a stir in recent months.Are they funny, disturbing, or cutting edge? Yes.After watching the crime-scene cookie video, Ms.

Fitzwater posted a video asking what many TikTok users have wondered: “Nutter Butter, you good??” The corporation responded with a clip of Nutter Butters with creepy human smiles.“Are we OK? Depend.

YES YES YES” flashed across the screen while the cookies danced over flames and a collage of backgrounds....